ND/NF: Balancing Between Silence and Singing: Claudia Llosa’s The Milk of Sorrow


Indigenous Peruvian Fausta (Magaly Solier), protagonist of director Claudia Llosa’s second feature The Milk of Sorrow, suffers her entire childhood and early adulthood from a condition referred to in her community as “la teta asustada,” translated in the film as “the milk of sorrow.” This affliction is believed to be transmitted to an infant who suckles from the breast of a raped and violated mother — as happened to Fausta’s mother and many of her neighbors in the village where Fausta was born during one of Peru’s periods of violent political upheaval.

The condition might not be listed in medical textbooks, but as far as popular notions go, Fausta would be a textbook case: burdened under a terror and sadness so heavy she rarely smiles, refusing to walk anywhere on the streets unaccompanied, and suffering from violent fainting spells and nosebleeds when she becomes overwrought. But despite a lifetime of certainty of the worst, Fausta hasn’t been entirely crushed. In the core of her being smolders an incredible power and beauty. When she is with her elderly mother there is joy and love. The film opens with Fausta listening to her grandmother sing. The sound of her song to my ears jangles at first with unfamiliarity, but compels me to listen and open myself to its authority. Fausta’s mother’s melody follows an order of the singer’s own devising — reminding me a little of the pansori performance opening Ch’unhyang (2000), an unfamiliar style requiring patience and attention to win me over.

Her mother’s lyrics, revealed through the subtitles, are grimmer than grim, evoking a darker time in Peru, full of anguish, rape at the hands of terrorists, the murder of husbands, a world many years before the film takes place. While I experience this strange disconnect between the eerie beauty of the song and the violence of the message, my heart surprises me by locating hope here between Fausta and her mother: the singer and listener have survived. But when Fausta’s mother dies, part of me fears that the private Fausta will herself die.

Another secret weighs at the core of Fausta’s physical body. Taking to heart the advice of one of Fausta’s mother’s neighbors for how to avoid rape during the years of terror, Fausta has inserted a potato deep into her vagina (Why a potato? Well, among other cultural significance to the potato in the region, Peru is said to be the birthplace of the potato).  Her mother’s neighbor had said that by making her body loathsome, she preserved her dignity. Indeed, the woman later removed the potato and bore her husband children. But the extremity of Fausta’s self-protection is out of step with the contemporary Peru she inhabits. When Fausta’s uncle brings her into the emergency room after the violent fainting spell that strikes her moments after the death of her mother, he tells the doctor of Fausta’s condition, victim of “la teta asustada.” The doctor isn’t interested in his abstract, poetic description of the “milk of sorrow”: he asks the uncle if he knows about the potato in Fausta’s vagina. An operation will be necessary to remove it before it causes her further injury: the potato has begun to sprout.

Fausta refuses to heed the contemporary world: she will not remove the potato, and turns her energy almost entirely to the question of how to transport her mother’s mummified body to the village where she was born for burial. And within the self-martyrdom of her refusal to believe her country can move beyond the terror of her early childhood, the seed of her mother’s secret singing begins, like the potato itself, to flower up inside her. And as the story develops, the film balances Fausta silence with the eruptions of her own singing, the purest concentration of her passion and feeling.

–Matthew Griffin

Buy Tickets:
Wed Apr 1: 6:15 (MoMA)
Fri Apr 3: 9 (FSLC)

Explore posts in the same categories: festival dispatches, New Directors/New Films, New Voices, on @ the walter reade

Tags: , , , , ,

You can comment below, or link to this permanent URL from your own site.

6 Comments on “ND/NF: Balancing Between Silence and Singing: Claudia Llosa’s The Milk of Sorrow”

  1. Gorki Says:

    This movie is awesome. Hope the director and actress get more attention in Hollywood. They are really brilliant people, amazing work they have done. So precious realism magic film and I wish the best for the producers, director and actress Magaly Solier.

  2. Miguel Griffin Says:

    I have the oportunity to see the first movie Madeinusa (same actress too) and was really impresed. THE MILK OF SORROW is such a great movie you can find everything inside: beauty, wonderful pictures and a real problem take it to the movie with talent and humility.
    I hope people like it as much as i did. Good luck to Claudia Llosa and Magaly Solier (a shine star on the screen)
    Miguel Griffin

  3. Matt Griffin, Film Society Correspondent Says:

    Quite a memorably film — I still keep thinking about this one, having seen it weeks ago. Will plan to see it again when it is released theatrically. Glad you folks got a chance to see and enjoy it!

  4. Yasser Zola Says:

    I am glad Director Claudia LLosa have accomplished such a mature film that deals with my country’s terrorism period (80’s)…when fausta sees the unknown military’s photograph she fears to bleed because during that time, atrocities where committed not only by the rebellious communist and terrorist party of Peru called ‘Shining Path’ (Sendero Luminoso) but by the military forces, while the church witnessed in silence the raping, the torturing and the killing…it is said that Perú has a fragile memory…though Llosa’s film comes as a balsam for the people who still carry injuries from terrorism regime …and as a reminder to the Peruvian State of that humiliating and bloody episode…

  5. Matt Griffin, Film Society Correspondent Says:

    Thank you for clarifying that moment with the photograph. I had assumed from the scene that the owner of the house was friendly with people in power that Fausta found upsetting, but I didn’t have the history to direct me more specifically.

  6. Roxana Says:

    I missed the premiere….. looking forward another premiere. Please let me know about the next premiere.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: